joe satriani - interact > talk to joe
{JS} Road Discography Gear Interact The Vault
[ Post Message ] [ View New Posts ] [ View All Posts ] [ Mark all as read ] [ Mark all unread ] [ View Archive Talk To Joe Posts ]
View messages from the last [ View Joe Messages Only ] 215369 posts by 17898 (of 168444) members
[Previous Page] { There are 38024 posts since Mon Feb 23 '09 12:44 pm PST }
Jump to page: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 >>
[Next Page]

cosmic_ape
Aron Ortega
Plays: Guitar (25 years)
1138 posts total | IP Logged


It's best to save up for a better guitar... I've put money on "improving" crappy guitars, not worth it!!!
Wed Feb 25 '09 2:19:28 pm Set this message as last read

Blue_Moon
Alan McKenna
Dublin
Ireland
Plays: Guitar (23 years)
6317 posts total | IP Logged
a guitar that plays nice doesnt have to be expensive!

more coldplay nonsence, i thought they would have got tired by now, ill be ignoring that
Wed Feb 25 '09 2:22:17 pm Set this message as last read

roo
Andrew Longhorn
iphone app: RooSatch
Australia
Plays: Guitar (34 years)
707 posts total | IP Logged

karusian: Ahhhh Daniel-san, first you must learn block! then you can learn punch!

Wax-on wax-off. Paint-da-fence.

Na-a-a-a-a-aa LOOK EYES! ALWAYS LOOK EYES!

Don't know, never been attacked by tree!

:)

Wed Feb 25 '09 2:26:06 pm Set this message as last read

roo
Andrew Longhorn
iphone app: RooSatch
Australia
Plays: Guitar (34 years)
707 posts total | IP Logged

either karate do yes, or karate do no.

if karate do maybe, then sooner or later "kssshhsh" - squish like grape!

Wed Feb 25 '09 2:26:52 pm Set this message as last read

GoldenGirl2
Millicent Moritz
Santa Clara, California
USA
Plays: Guitar (15 years)
876 posts total | IP Logged

Austin, Austin, Austin---You make this Cali woman proud with your response to ColdPlay.

Also, I haven't heard of Porcupine Tree. I'll have to look them up.

Cosmic_ape--Thanks for Rosenberg Trio music.

Mr. McKenna--When are you going to ask M. London out for an evening? I'm surprised you haven't gotten together to jam.

Michelle--Something strange has been happening in this forum and it seems to be following you. Silly troll! It should know better than to interrupt Mighty Michelle! She could turn on it with all her guns blazing! Woooooo Hoooooo!!!

Chee101 Tracie--Please speak to me. I have been running into brick walls lately with this stupid disease! The medications don't always work like they're sposed to.

Zenfish--Are you the "real" son of a fish that Joe was talking about???

GoldenGirl2

Wed Feb 25 '09 2:28:48 pm Set this message as last read

Skippygirl

2103 posts total | IP Logged

CommodoreDrake - step into my office.;0)...........I started learning guitar on 28 Dec so it's only been about 8 weeks but maybe this wil be useful to you.

1. Plenty of kind and helpful people on this site who tolerate all the dumb questions I ask and provide helpful info and tips.

2. I got hold of an old acoustic to use and started learning chords from the Dummies Guide to Guitar. It was a pretty bad old guitar but good to see if I was going to continue. Last week I got a 2nd hand Fender acoustic off ebay ($150) which is perfect and lovely to play so now I practice on that. There is usually someone with a guitar you can borrow.

3. I got the Hal Leonard book on ebay and there are also a heap of websites for beginners, e.g. justinguitar.com is a good one. You can get any song up on youtube if you want to hear how it is meant to be played.

4. I spoke with all the people I know who can play guitar and asked them about chords, notes, practice, what order they learnt things in etc. guitar palyers are always keen to talk about it

I try to practice 20-30 mins per day but being a Mum sometimes that don't work.

Hope this helps.

Wed Feb 25 '09 2:35:18 pm Set this message as last read

cosmic_ape
Aron Ortega
Plays: Guitar (25 years)
1138 posts total | IP Logged


A lot of guitars play nice, but the more you learn about them the more you realize you need to check for intonation, tuning, pickup issues and all that crap...

I bought that cheap Ibanez and I thought it was very good until I bought the prestige one, and I realized the tremolo was shit... It plays great, I love the neck, but I have tuning problems... and I swapped the pups, too...

Now, I know better... being lefty means you don't get to try guitars, so you end up buying off the internet... now I'm hunting them down and playing as many as I can find... The GC here in Hollywood has 5 lefty strats, I only like two of them, and only one feels "just right"... If I had the cash, I'd get right now...

Oh, being broke... gotta love it...


Wed Feb 25 '09 2:37:51 pm Set this message as last read

roo
Andrew Longhorn
iphone app: RooSatch
Australia
Plays: Guitar (34 years)
707 posts total | IP Logged

Oh come on, "Daniel Caruso"? he's obviously the Karate kid!

Either that or it's Ralph Macchio pretending to be the Karate Kid..

Wed Feb 25 '09 2:41:14 pm Set this message as last read

trollgarden

15 posts total | IP Logged


Edited Fri Feb 27 '09 9:24 am
Wed Feb 25 '09 3:17:28 pm Set this message as last read

Blue_Moon
Alan McKenna
Dublin
Ireland
Plays: Guitar (23 years)
6317 posts total | IP Logged
the cheap ibanez trems suck alrite, there not to bad but dont compare tot he prestige, i hate the way my ibanez plays sometimes, makes hard work of some things

and quick someone rob the name coldplay while it unused
Wed Feb 25 '09 3:19:59 pm Set this message as last read

slanshroom
roy marchbank
Scotland, Barcelona
Spain
Plays: Guitar (51 years)
3677 posts total | IP Logged
Quality not quantity.....a cheap acoustic/electric however well it plays sounds cheap b4 & after its plugged in.....that doesnt happen when the price tag goes up.... your finger tone gets shoved into overdrive so IF y have the bucks...find yer luthier
Wed Feb 25 '09 3:22:47 pm Set this message as last read

Blue_Moon
Alan McKenna
Dublin
Ireland
Plays: Guitar (23 years)
6317 posts total | IP Logged
aw, I didnt even come in the top 15 of that guitar contest i entered there the other week, gotta admit i hate the vast majority of the entries in it :)
Wed Feb 25 '09 3:27:08 pm Set this message as last read

slanshroom
roy marchbank
Scotland, Barcelona
Spain
Plays: Guitar (51 years)
3677 posts total | IP Logged

The problem with guitar these days is competition.Shouldnt it be about composition?I mean if a guitarist could dazzle me with 6 billion notes a minute i,d put him in a circus

When i pray will guitarists look beyond technique n get down t creating great music

Wed Feb 25 '09 3:40:27 pm Set this message as last read

loll
Lol Mettam
Plymouth, Devon
UK
Plays: Guitar (44 years)
69 posts total | IP Logged
@GG2: Also, I haven't heard of Porcupine Tree. I'll have to look them up.
Oh boy! Get yourself a copy of 'Fear of a Blank Planet', turn the lights down, turn the volume up and immerse yourself in the coolness. 'In Absentia' has some great tracks too but I say try FOABP first.

@CommodoreDrake: I wouldn't get the best acoustic you can afford just yet but do go for an instrument that is at least half decent. A cheap instrument might well put you off for life. Something from the likes of Yamaha that costs around $500 should be pretty fine. Try to get the store to set it up for you. It might add a bit to the bill but if their repairs guy is any good it'll be worth it. Also, don't rule out a good second-hand instrument either. I bought a s/h Takamine from a pro player. It's fantastic. Cost me half the price of a new one. Money very well spent. I don't mind the few dings and scratches; it means I don't have to be precious about it and I can leave it out on a stand ready for picking up at any time. A good hard case is def. worth it if you want to take your guitar around with you. Accidents happen all too frequently with acoustics in gig bags. Don't learn the hard way, get a hard case! :o)
L8r, Lol
Wed Feb 25 '09 4:07:57 pm Set this message as last read

CommodoreDrake
Dustyn McCormick
Topeka, Ks
USA
12 posts total | IP Logged

Wow lots of great info. Now another question, everyone seems to be talking about acoustic vs. electric, but what about steel guitars. I love the sound of those as well. Probably won't start in that area but it'd be cool to eventually get there.

Looking at the prices ya'll have quoted I'm probably going to have to go with a second hand which is fine. I just don't really have the money to go new. I'm in the process of starting a new business so that tends to suck up quite a bit of my disposable income. Five years at it so far and still not making any type of money... well that's a lie made four hundred in profit this year but that all goes right back in.

So I looked at used online and realized I need to figure out what size I need... so apparently it's first to a music store to see what size I need and then to look for a second hand.

Drake

Edited Wed Feb 25 '09 5:28 pm

Wed Feb 25 '09 5:09:10 pm Set this message as last read

cosmic_ape
Aron Ortega
Plays: Guitar (25 years)
1138 posts total | IP Logged


ibanez_god, I got my first Ibanez ONLINE from a franchise guitar store... the second time around I went with a mom and pop lil' shop and they hooked me up... this was also online... That's what you get when you are left handed... the first time I didn't know any better, now I'd like to think it's different...

I am still forced to buy online, as the best guitars I've found are in shops located in the NY area... the funny part, they're built here in Southern California... Go figure!


Wed Feb 25 '09 5:35:44 pm Set this message as last read

death cube k

6054 posts total | IP Logged
CommodoreDrake if your getting an acoustic, get something with at least a solid top as that is the main sound board.. you can get a takamine G seiries for around the $300 range with a solid top.. you can get a real nice canadian made simon and patrick acoustic with solid top for about $425 or so . or a taylor 114 t for under $800 .. let us know what you get ..also try to get some light strings put on, as that will help you play easier
Wed Feb 25 '09 7:22:59 pm Set this message as last read

GoldenGirl2
Millicent Moritz
Santa Clara, California
USA
Plays: Guitar (15 years)
876 posts total | IP Logged

Al McKenna--Why is Ireland so...so...Roman Catholic? Don't they accept freedom of all kinds of religions? I can't figure that out. What does it matter if you visit a priest or a vicar? I don't like the attitude toward diversity and my brother/friend and his lifestyle (why would anyone choose that lifestyle?) I think he and his domestic partner should be able to get married if they want to. He's a great guy and I should know 'cause we met in high school and we were the best of friends. People can be so weird about these things. I mean peoples sex lives are very complex and some people don't want to admit it.

GoldenGirl2

Wed Feb 25 '09 9:38:03 pm Set this message as last read

GoldenGirl2
Millicent Moritz
Santa Clara, California
USA
Plays: Guitar (15 years)
876 posts total | IP Logged

SkippyGirl--I didn't know you had an office in here. What color paint or wallpaper did you use and what does your desk look like?

GoldenGirl2

Wed Feb 25 '09 9:41:32 pm Set this message as last read

GoldenGirl2
Millicent Moritz
Santa Clara, California
USA
Plays: Guitar (15 years)
876 posts total | IP Logged

LOL! Have ya'll noticed how the Aussies and Canadians have been flirtin' with each other in this space? Also they been flirtin' with the President of the United States and sendin' him flowers and gifts. Such flattery will get them everywhere!!!!!!!!!! Awwwww shucks....you guys! ;-0)

GoldenGirl2

Wed Feb 25 '09 9:46:11 pm Set this message as last read

Skippygirl

2103 posts total | IP Logged

To all the guitar players- Dumb Question #22 -

I started on the A pentatonic and was using the same approach as chords i.e. arched fingers so as not to touch other strings etc but then I went back to the vids of PipSatrini (daddy long legs fingers) and Blue Moony and Joe I noticed that they actually keep their fingers quite straightish and parallel to the finger board and just tap the end of their fingers on each string - so my question is does it not matter that you might touch the other strings (since you are only picking one) or are you somehow not touching them at all?

2nd part of Dumb Question - is it better technique to only have 1 finger on 1 string at a time or is it OK to keep a string depressed if your next note is not affected i.e. playing F on the 1st string then G can I leave the F depressed - it's easier.

Cheers in advance.

Wed Feb 25 '09 10:43:33 pm Set this message as last read

Zenfish

4324 posts total | IP Logged

Slansh : i share your statement about competition polluting composition.

But as you know, competition is an easier way than composition. & people do what they are able to do.

Edit : i just would like to add that if, across this democratic competition, a musician bets onto composition, how many luck does he get to be heard?

Very few.

& there's lot of musicians who bet onto composition.

That's one of the big democratic paradox.

Edited Thu Feb 26 '09 12:11 am

Wed Feb 25 '09 11:09:44 pm Set this message as last read

cosmic_ape
Aron Ortega
Plays: Guitar (25 years)
1138 posts total | IP Logged


SkippyGirl, first part, it has to do with two things:

At first you need to over emphasize the fretting in order to get it right and avoid injuries due to awkward positioning. On top of that, your fingers need to loosen up and get used to the guitar related motions (they're muscles and you need to build them up like an athlete)... Once you reach that stage, you will find that you don't need to move your fingers as much in order to get places... your fingers will have gained some skill around the fretboard and you will find that you can optimize your fretting with less finger movement...

number 2. what you have seen is these guys playing pentatonic scales, right? well, the basic pentatonic box has your index finger fretting one note on each string, at the same fret. This means that you can almost barre your fingers across that fret almost as if you were playing an F chord, for example(not quite across the whole set of strings, but two or three at a time)...
On top of that, pentatonics call for blues and blues calls for string bending, so your hand needs to be on a certain angle in order for it to able to bend strings effectively... And, if you must know, these guys probably had some kind of distortion going on, so that's another issue...
Once you play guitar with some sort of gain on your signal, you have to adapt your technique to the point that if you strum across the only note(s) you will hear is/are the one(s) you meant to play. Everything else needs to be muted or it will sound like crap... This is not so important when playing acoustic and too much to think of when you're just getting started...

Hope that helps...


Wed Feb 25 '09 11:39:09 pm Set this message as last read

Skippygirl

2103 posts total | IP Logged

Cosmic Ape - Aha!!! (slaps forehead) that makes sense, thanks for that detailed description I appreciate it. I was watching Pip play Extremist and it's ike a spider crawling over the frets so you can see the economy of finger movement - maybe in a year or so I'll nail it.

Will be heading to guitar lessons soon, have to wait for the stars to align.......

edit - thanks ibanez-god, too.

Edited Wed Feb 25 '09 11:49 pm

Wed Feb 25 '09 11:48:25 pm Set this message as last read

cosmic_ape
Aron Ortega
Plays: Guitar (25 years)
1138 posts total | IP Logged


to answer the 2nd part of your question(and you thought I had forgotten!)...

is it better technique to only have 1 finger on 1 string at a time or is it OK to keep a string depressed if your next note is not affected i.e. playing F on the 1st string then G can I leave the F depressed - it's easier.

well, that answer has two parts also:
1. It depends on where you're going. In order to play through the song changes without falling behind on the tempo you have to learn to anticipate your next movement. It's like when you are driving, you don't stare at the road that is right in front of your hood... You keep your chin up and look at the road that is a couple of feet in front of you and its surroundings... So that pattern of "driving through the changes" will dictate the fingerings and the different ways you can play the same chords...

2. I wouldn't advice to leave your finger there just to make it easier on you. Yes, your next finger won't have to press as hard, but this might come and bite you later on. Then, you might find afterward that it is hard for you to change to certain chords because your hand is stuck somewhere else. I say deal with the pressure and get your fingers used to it. You will have less fingers to drag to the next position.

Again, it depends on where you're going... If you're coming back to that position, sure... why not?


Wed Feb 25 '09 11:56:12 pm Set this message as last read
[Previous Page] Jump to page: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 >> [Next Page]
Try the Advanced Search (Beta)

SHARE THIS PAGE
[ ©1995-2010 joe satriani ]--[ site by chime ]--[ credits ]--[ contact ]
You are using this browser: Mozilla/5.0 AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko; compatible; ClaudeBot/1.0; +claudebot@anthropic.com)